¶àÄêǰ£¬´ÓÓàӢʱÀÏʦ¿ÚÖУ¬³õ´Î»ñϤËûµÄ´óÃû¡£Ó¢Ê±Ê¦¶ÔËûµÄÎ÷·½Ñ§ÎÊÍÆ³ç±¸ÖÁ£¬ÓÖ¶ÔËûµÄ¡¶Î÷Óμǡ·Ó¢ÒëÔÞ²»¾ø¿Ú¡£ÓÉÓÚӢʱʦº±¼ûÈç´Ë³ÆÓþһλѧÕߣ¬ËùÒÔÎÒ¶Ô¡°Óà¹ú·ª¡±ÕâÈý¸ö×Ö£¬±ãÁôϼ«Éî¿ÌµÄÓ¡Ïó¡£Ó¢Ê±Ê¦ºÍËûËäÊôͬÐÕ£¬²¢ÎÞͬ×ÚÖ®Òꣻµ«Á½ÀÏÏàÖªÏàµÃ£¬ÇéͬÊÖ×ã¡£
ËäÈ»£¬ÎÒÓëÓà½ÌÊÚͨ¹ýÏÖ´ú·Éºè£¨µçÓÊ£©¶øÀ´ÍùÈÈÂ磬µ«ËµÆðÀ´ÈÕºóÒ²½öÓÐÒ»ÃæÖ®Ôµ¡£¶þ©–©–ÆßÄ꣬ËûӦ̨Íå¡°ÖÐÑÐÔº¡±µÄÑûÔ¼£¬µ½Ôº·¢±íÁËÕñÁû·¢ñùµÄÑݽ²¡°ÈËÎÄѧ¿ÆºÎÒÔ²»ÊÇ¿ÆÑ§£¿©¤´Ó±È½ÏµÄ½Ç¶È×ÔÑÇÀïÊ¿¶àµÂµÄ¹Ûµã̸Æð¡±£¨Why the Humanities Are Not Science: Thinking Comparatively from Aristotle£©¡£ËûÓɹŽñÖÐÍâ֪ʶ·ÖÀàµÄÑÝ±ä£¬ÖØÉêÈËÎÄѧµÄ»ù±¾Á¢³¡¡£´ÓÑÇÀíÊ¿¶àµÂµÄÊӽǼÓÒÔÆÌ³Â£¬Õý±¾ÇåÔ´£¬¾«±Ù¾øÂ×£¬³ä·ÖÏÔÏÖ³öËû¶ÔÎ÷·½ÈËÎÄѧ´«Í³µÄÕÆÎÕ¡£ºóÀ´Óà½ÌÊÚ½«Õâ´ÎÓ¢ÎÄÑݽ²Ìíд³ÉÂÛÎÄ¿¯ÐУ¬¸üÊܵ½Ñ§½çµÄÖØÊÓ¡£Óà½ÌÊÚÖ®ËùÒÔ°ÑÕâÆªÂÛÎÄÏ׸øÔøÔÚÖ¥´ó¹²Ê¹ýµÄ·¨¹úÕÜѧ¼Ò¡ª¡ªÀï¿Æ½ÌÊÚ£¨Paul Ricur, 1913-2005£©£¬¸ÇÁ½È˵ÄѧÎÊͬµ÷¶ú¡£
³Ã×Å´Ë·¬Ñݽ²Ö®±ã£¬ÎÒÓëÄÚÈËÔ¼ÁËÓà½ÌÊÚǰÍùÖøÃûµÄ¼ªÆ·²ÍÌüÓòͣ¬ÔÚÈ¥³Ì³µÉÏÁì½ÌÁËËû¸ß³¬µÄÒôÀÖËØÑø¡£µ±Ê±³µÀïÕý²¥·Å°Í¹þ£¨Johann S. Bach, 1685-1750£©µÄ¡¶Ó¢¹ú×éÇú¡·£¨The English Suites£©£¬²»³ö¶þÊ®Ã룬Óà½ÌÊÚ±ãÖ¸³öÑÝ×àÕßÄ˼ÓÄôóµÄ¸ñÂס¤¹Å¶ûµÂ£¨Glenn H. Gould, 1932-1982£©¡£ËûµÄÈËÎÄÆ·Î¶£¬ÊµÓë´ÓС¼ÒÍ¥µÄÑø³É½ÌÓýÓйء££¨ÈÕºó£¬ÎÒ·½²ÅµÃÖªËûż¶û»¹»áÌæÖ¥¼Ó¸çµÄ±¨Ö½×«Ð´ÀÖÆÀÄØ£¡£©²»Òâ¼ä£¬ÎÒÃÇÓÖ·¢¾õÓà½ÌÊÚÄËÆ·Î¶Éõ¸ßµÄÀÏ÷Ò£¨gourmet£©£¬Çþ×ÔÚ¼³ýÁË»áÆ·³¢Ê³Î³øÒÕÒ಻ÂäÓÚÈ˺󣬻¹ÑûÎÒÓг¯Ò»ÈÕÔì·ÃÖ¥¼Ó¸ç£¬Ëû¿Éϳø´óÏÔÉíÊÖ£¨·¨²Í£©¡£Ï¯¼ä£¬ÎÒÃǽ»Ì¸¸÷¹ú²ÍµãµÄÓÅÁÓ£¬²¢ÒÔ˼ÏëÉϵÄÎ÷ѧ×ô²Í£¬ÈÚ¾«ÉñÓëÎïÖÊÓÚһ¯£¬Ï²ÀÖÈÚÈÚ£¬Ïà¼ûºÞÍí£¬¸ÃÒ¹ËÆºõÓÐ̸²»¾¡µÄ»°Ìâ¡£
ÓÐÒ»»Ø£¬ÎÒÒòË×ÃûÖ®À۸е½¾ÚÉ¥¡£´ÓÎ´Ä±ÃæµÄÓà½ÌÊÚµÃÖª£¬¾¹´ÓÔ¶·½ÉÓÀ´³¤¼ã£¬ÒÔÇ×ÉíµÄ¾ÀúÓëÎÒ¹²Ã㣬ÁîÎҼȸÐÒâÍ⣬¸´ÓÖÌáÕñÐÄÉñ¡£
Óà¹ú·ª½ÌÊÚÔÚÎ÷·½Ñ§½çËØÒÔ²©Ñ§Öø³Æ£¬ÎÊѧºá¿çÖÐÎ÷¡£ËäÈ»ËûÔÚ»ªÎÄѧ½çͬÑùÏíÓÐÊ¢Ãû£¬µ«ÆäѧÎʵĹæÄ££¬È´¾ø·Ç¡°ººÑ§¡±Ò»Óò¿ÉÒÔ·¶Î§¡£ËûÔÚÖ¥´óͬʱÊÜÆ¸ÓÚÎå¸ö²»Í¬Ñ§Ïµ£ºÉñѧԺ¡¢±È½ÏÎÄѧϵ¡¢Ó¢ÎÄϵ¡¢¶«ÑÇϵ¡¢Éç»á˼ÏëίԱ»á£¨committee on social thoughts£©£¬¸ÇÊô¾øÎÞ½öÓУ¬¶øÎªÓÑÅóËù½ò½òÀÖµÀ£¬×ãʾËûÖÎѧ¹æÄ£µÄ¿í¹ãÓëºêÔ¶£¬·ÇÒ»°ãר¼ÒѧÕß¿ÉÒÔ±ÈÄâ¡£
Óà¹ú·ªÓëÓàӢʱµÈ½ÌÊڵĺÏÓ°±¾ÎÄ·¢±íÓÚ2015Äê10Ô¡¶Êé³Ç¡·ÔÓÖ¾£¬ÅìÅÈÐÂΞÊÚÈ¨×ªÔØ¡£Íùºó£¬ÎÒÿÓвÝ×÷£¬éü³ÊÇë¹ýÄ¿£¬Ø½ÇóËûµÄÖ¸Õý¡£Óà½ÌÊÚÔòÓÐÇó±ØÓ¦£¬²»ÁßÓèÒÔ»ØÓ¦£¬ÈÃÎÒÊÜÒæ·Ëdz¡£ÓÚÎÒ¶øÑÔ£¬Óà½ÌÊÚ²»à´ÎªÒàʦÒàÓѵÄÍüÄêÖ®½»¡£Å¼·êÄê½Ú£¬ÎÒ±ã¼Äȥ̨ÍåÃûÆ·¡ª¡ª¶³¶¥ÎÚÁú£¬ÁıíÐÄÒâ¡£Óà½ÌÊÚ×ÜÊÇ¿ÍÆøµØÀ´º¯ÔÞ²»¾ø¿Ú£¬×ÐϸÃèÊöÆäÖÐÔÏζ¡£Ö±µ½È¥Ä꣨2014£©£¬ËûͻȻ·¢À´µçÓÊ£¬Î½ÓÉÓÚî¾»¼Ðļ²£¬Ò½ÉúÖö¸ÀËû²»ÄÜÒû²è£¬ÒªÎҾʹ˴òס¡£½ÓÐøµÄµçÓÊ£¬±ã¸æÖª²¡Í´Óë½û¼É£¬ÎÒÔÚÍòÀïÖ®Íâ£¬ÊøÊÖÎ޲ߣ¬Î¯ÊµÌæËû¹ÒÐÄ¡£²»ÒâÉÔǰ£¬ÓÐһҪʱØÐëÏòËûÙ÷±¨£¬È´¾Ã¾Ãδ»ñ»Ø¸´£¬ÐÄÖаµ¾õ²»Ãî¡£²»Ð©Ê±£¬±ã´«À´ËûµÄجºÄ£¬ÁîÈË´íãµ£¬¸ÐÉËÄÑÒÑ¡£
Ö®ºó£¬ÕØ×ÔÎÄ×ÖÒòÔµ£¬ÎÒÓÐÐÒ½áʶÓà¹ú·ª½ÌÊÚ¡£Æð×ÔÒ»¾Å¾Å¡ðÄê´ú£¬ÎÒ¿ªÊ¼·¢±íÒ»Á¬´®Ì½ÌÖ¿×ÃíÎÄ»¯µÄÂÛÎÄ£»²¢´ÓÔÏÈÖ»ÎöÂÛ¿×ÃíÓëÊ¿ÈË¡¢Í³ÖÎÕߵĹØÏµ£¬Öð½¥Ïò×Ú½ÌÎÄ»¯µÄÁìÓòÑÓÉì¡£Ô±¾Îª×Ú½ÌÊ·´ó¼ÒµÄÓà½ÌÊÚ£¬¼«ÆäÃôÈñµØ×¢Òâµ½ÎÒµÄÑо¿¶¯Ïò¡£¶øÎÒÔò¼ä½Ó´ÓӢʱʦ¿ÚÖУ¬µÃÖªËû¶ÔÎÒÕâЩÑо¿µÄ¿Ï¶¨¡£¶þ©–©–ÎåÄ꣬ËûÔÚÓ¢ÎÄÖø×÷¡¶ÖйúµÄ¹ú¼ÒÓë×ڽ̡·£¨State and Religion in China: Historical and Textual Perspectives£©Ò»ÊéÀ¶ÔÎÒµÄÑо¿°ýÑïÓмӣ¬ÊµÄ˶ԺóÉúС±²µÄÒçÃÀÖ®´Ê¶ú¡£
ÔÚÓà½ÌÊÚ´ÇÊÀ֮ǰ£¬ÓÐÁ½¼þÊÂÈÃÎÒÒì³£¸Ð¶¯£¬ÖµµÃÌá±ÊÒ»Êé¡£ÆäÒ»£¬ËûʱʱÒÔ¸ß×㡪¡ªÀîŠ]ѧÐÖ¡ªµÄѧÊõ·¢Õ¹ÎªÄî¡£Ôø¾Ôڵ绰À·´¸´¸úÎÒ¶£ßÌ¡£Æäʵ£¬Š]ѧÐÖæµÊìÃ÷ÇåÖ®¼ÊÖÐÎ÷ÎÄ»¯µÄ½»Á÷£¬ËûµÄѧÎÊÎÒÔçÒÑÓÐËùÁìÂÔ£¬²¢²»ÓÃÓà½ÌÊÚÌØ±ð½»´ý¡£Š]ѧÐÖ¾«Í¨ÊýÖÖÎ÷ÓËûÑо¿Ã÷ÇåʱÆÚµÄ·ÒëÎÄÀ࣬ÓÃÁ¦ÆÄÉ´ËÄ˶ÀÃÅ֮ѧ£¬¶øÎªËûÈËËùÄÑÆó¼°¡£¸öÈËÔÚѧÊõÉÏ·²ÓöÎ÷ÎÄ£¨ÈçÀ¶¡ÎÄ£©µÄÎÊÌ⣬±ãËæÊ±ÖµçÇë½Ì£¬Á¢»ñ½â´ð¡£
ÁíÒ»Ôò£¬¶þ©–Ò»ËÄÄêËûÑ¡ÔñÁ˺ÍÖ¥´óͬÊ¡ª¡ªÖªÃûµÄÈËÀàѧ¼ÒɳÁÖ£¨Marshall Sahlins, b. 1930£©¡ª¡ª²¢¼ç×÷Õ½£¬Í¬Éù·´¶ÔÖ¥´óÉèÁ¢Ä³Ò»»ú¹¹£¬Î¨¿ÖºóÕßÓÐÒÔÕþÖθÉԤѧÊõ¶ÀÁ¢Ö®ÓÝ¡£ÄǶÎʱ¼äÿÿÉϰ࣬éüÊÕµ½µçÓÊ£¬ÎÒÒ»Ò»°Ý¶ÁËûÃǵÄÀí¾Ý¡£Á½ÀÏά»¤Ñ§Êõ¶ÀÁ¢µÄ¼á¶¨¾öÐÄÓë×÷Ϊ£¬ÁîÈ˸ÐÅåÍò·Ö¡£
Æäʵ£¬Óà½ÌÊÚÖ®ËùÒÔ¶Ô×¾×÷Éî¸ÐÐËȤ£¬ÓëÉÏÊÀ¼ÍÖøÃûµÄÉñѧºÍ×Ú½ÌÊ·¼ÒÒÁÀûÑǵ£¨Mircea Eliade,1907-1986£©Óйء£Óà½ÌÊÚÔøÉϹýÒÁÊϵĿΣ¬ËûÓ̼ǵÃÒÁÊÏÓÚ̽ÌÖ¡°×ڽ̡±µÄ±¾ÖÊ£¬ÔøÌرð¹Ø×¢ÉñÊ¥µÄ¿Õ¼ä¡¢Ê±¼ä¡¢Éñ»°µÈ¹¹³ÉÒòËØ£¬¶øÊܵ½Ñ§½çµÄעĿ£¨Mircea Eliade, The Sacred and the Profane: The Nature of Religion, trans. by Willard R. Trask, New York: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, 1959)¡£ÏÔÈ»£¬¿×Ãí±ãÊÇÈå½ÌµÄÊ¥Óò£¬µ«ÎÒÑо¿¿×Ãí´¿³öżȻ£¬ÓëÒÁÀûÑǵµÄѧ˵²¢ÎÞ¹ØÁª¡£¿ÉÊÇÒÁÊϵÄÑÔ˵£¬È´ÎÞÒâÖбä³ÉÓà½ÌÊÚÓëÎÒÖ®¼äµÄÐÄÁéÇÅÁº¡£

¼ÇµÃӢʱʦ¾ÙÁËÒ»¶ÎÒëÎÄΪÀý£¬ÆäÖÐÉæ¼°·ð½Ì¡¢µÀ½ÌµÄרҵ֪ʶ£¬²¢·ÇÒ»°ãÒëÕß¿ÉÒÔʤÈΣ»¶øÓà¹ú·ª½ÌÊÚÒëµÃ²»½ö±Þ±ÙÈëÀ¶øÇÒÉú¶¯´«Éñ¡£Èç¹ûÎҼǵò»´í£¬µ±Ê±Ó¢Ê±Ê¦Ø½ÏëÂÞÖÂÓà¹ú·ª½ÌÊÚµ½¹þ·ð´óѧÈν̣¬µ«ÒòÖ¥¼Ó¸ç´óѧǿÁÒοÁôÓà¹ú·ª½ÌÊÚ£¬ÖÕδ³ÉÐС£
Óà¹ú·ª½ÌÊÚ£¨Anthony¡¡C.Yu,1938-2015£©ÓÚºó±²Ñ§Õß³£±íÏÖ³ö³¤ÕßÖ®°®£¬ÎÒ±ãÊÇÆäÖÐһλÊÜÒæÕß¡£
¶þ©–Ò»ËÄÄêÎÒÓ¦±±¾©´óѧÖÐÎÄϵ³ÂƽԽÌÊÚÖ®Ñû£¬´ÓÊ¡¶Èå½ÌÊ¥Óò¡·µÄ±àÑ¡£¬ÓÉÓÚÕâ¸öÒéÌâÏòΪÓà¹ú·ª½ÌÊÚËùºñ°®£¬Òò´ËÎÒ¶·µ¨ÒÔÕⱾѡ¼¯·îÏ׸øËû£¬½åÒÔ±í´ï¶ÔËûµÄ»³Ä²¢¸ÐлËû¶Ô¸öÈËÑо¿¿×Ãíһ·×ßÀ´µÄ¹ÄÀøºÍÖ§³Ö¡£½üÄ꣬ËûÓÈÆä²»ÑáÆä·³£¬ÔÙÈý´ß´ÙÎÒ¶¯ÊÖ׫дһ±¾Ó¢ÎÄ׍ָ£¬×ÛºÏ֮ǰ̽ÌÖ¿×ÃíµÄÐĵã¬ÙÂÓëÎ÷·½×Ú½ÌÊ·¼ÒÖ±½Ó¶Ô»°¡£Óà½ÌÊÚÈÏΪÎÒ¾Û½¹×ڽ̡¶ÉñÊ¥¿Õ¼ä¡·µÄÊÖ·¨±ðÓÐÌØÉ«£¬ÈÝÓëÎ÷·½±È½Ï×Ú½Ìѧ½ç»¥Ïà²ÎÕÕ¡£µ«¸öÈËÒòÁíÓÐÆäËûÑо¿¿ÎÌâ¿ÌÔÚ½øÐУ¬·ÖÉí·¦Êõ£¬Ò»Ê±Ö»Óй¼¸ºËûµÄºÃÒ⡣ΨһÉԿɲ¹³¥µÄÊÇ£¬¸öÈËØü¹Ø¿×ÃíµÄÑо¿²»¾Ã½«ÓÐÁ½´ó²áÈÕÒë±¾¿¯ÐУ¬Èݿɻر¨ËûµÄºñÍû¡£ÖÁÓÚ׫ÊöÓ¢ÎÄ×¨ÖøÒ»Ê£¬ÔòÓÌ´ýÀ´ÈÕµÄŬÁ¦ÁË£¬ÅÎʱʱÒԴ˱޲ß×Ô¼º¡£